Newcastle and Everton will know each other very well by Monday night. That is because they meet in the EFL Cup at Goodison's successor, the Hill Dickinson Stadium, just four days earlier. Our Newcastle vs Everton prediction is for the Premier League rematch at St James' Park, which kicks off at 20:00 UTC on Monday 2 November 2026. Newcastle come in after a 2-0 win at Crystal Palace, while Everton were beaten 2-0 at Arsenal.

Newcastle vs Everton Prediction: Where the Game Will Be Won

Newcastle have been hard to predict. In addition, in their last five games they won 2-0 at Selhurst Park and beat Hull 2-1. But they also lost 1-0 at home to Aston Villa and were thrashed 4-1 at both Coventry and Leeds. That adds up to six goals scored and ten conceded. Moreover, for our Newcastle vs Everton prediction, the key point is that this team can play very well and very badly in the same month.

On top of that, Everton have lost their last two league games without scoring, 2-0 at home to Chelsea and 2-0 at Arsenal. In addition, before that they drew 2-2 at Hull and beat Ipswich and Wolves 1-0. Moreover, they have scored four and conceded six across those five matches. On the other hand, four of Everton's last five games stayed under 2.5 goals. So they are rarely involved in open shootouts.

Newcastle vs Everton: Key Stats

  • Newcastle form: 2 wins, 0 draws and 3 defeats in the last 5
  • Everton form: 2 wins, 1 draw and 2 defeats in the last 5
  • Goals: Newcastle 6 scored and 10 conceded, Everton 4 scored and 6 conceded
  • Clean sheets: Newcastle 1, Everton 2
  • Over 2.5 goals: Newcastle 3 of 5, Everton 1 of 5
  • Both teams scored: Newcastle 3 of 5, Everton 1 of 5
  • Head-to-head: Newcastle 10 wins, 5 draws, Everton 16 wins (31 meetings per FotMob)

Head-to-Head Record

FotMob lists 31 meetings between the clubs, with 16 Everton wins, ten for Newcastle and five draws. That is a better record for the visitors than many would expect. However, the EFL Cup tie on 29 October will add one more meeting before this game. Also, its result could shape the mood for Monday.

Newcastle vs Everton prediction form guide

The Matchup That Matters: Newcastle's attack vs Everton's compact block

Everton have kept two clean sheets in their last five games. Also, their best performances come when they sit in a compact shape and defend their box. On top of that, Newcastle, by contrast, have scored in four of their last five. In addition, if the hosts move the ball quickly through the middle, they can open up a side that has not scored in two league games. Moreover, if not, Everton can frustrate them and hope for a set piece.

Likely Game Flow

Newcastle should have more of the ball at home, especially with a full St James' Park behind them on a Monday night. On top of that, Everton are likely to defend deep and break when they can. Because the cup tie comes first, both managers may rotate, and that could make the game scrappy. Overall, our Newcastle vs Everton analysis expects a tight contest in which the home side edges it.

Injuries and Suspensions

FotMob lists Ewen Jaouen (hamstring, early December) and Valentino Livramento (knock, early November) as injured for Newcastle, with Anthony Elanga doubtful and Jacob Ramsey back in training. In addition, Everton have no unavailable players on the page. Because the two sides meet in the cup first, check the confirmed line-ups about an hour before kick-off.

When to Watch

Before you lock in your Newcastle vs Everton tips, check the start time where you live. Moreover, Newcastle and Everton kick off at 20:00 UTC (21:00 CET) on Monday 2 November 2026 at St James' Park in Newcastle. On top of that, in practice, that is 15:00 ET in Canada, 20:00 GMT in the UK, 21:00 WAT in Nigeria, 22:00 SAST in South Africa, 23:00 EAT in Kenya, 01:30 (early next day) IST in India and 21:00 CET across central Europe. However, broadcast rights differ by country. So check your local broadcaster before the game. Also, remember that kick-off times can change for television.

Betting Angles for Our Newcastle vs Everton Tips

Newcastle to win is our main play for this Newcastle vs Everton prediction. That is because they are at home and Everton have failed to score in their last two league games. In addition, under 3.5 goals is the value angle: four of Everton's last five games stayed under that line. Moreover, for a bigger price, Newcastle to win to nil is worth a look, given Everton's scoring problems.

  • Main tip: Newcastle to win
  • Value tip: Under 3.5 goals
  • Bonus tip: Newcastle to win to nil
  • Predicted score: Newcastle 2-0 Everton

Final Newcastle vs Everton Tips

Our final selection is:

Pick: Newcastle to win

Final Thoughts

Altogether, Newcastle have more quality going forward and Everton are struggling to score. On top of that, our Newcastle vs Everton prediction is a home win, most likely without Everton finding the net. Looking for more previews? Our Crystal Palace vs Liverpool preview and Man United vs Aston Villa preview cover the next fixtures. Meanwhile, the official Premier League website has the full table.

FAQ

What is your Newcastle vs Everton prediction?

We back Newcastle. Our Newcastle vs Everton preview is a 2-0 home win.

When is Newcastle vs Everton?

In short, Newcastle and Everton kick off at 20:00 UTC (21:00 CET) on Monday 2 November 2026 at St James' Park in Newcastle.

Do Newcastle and Everton play twice in a week?

Yes. They meet in the EFL Cup on Thursday 29 October at Everton, then again in the Premier League on Monday 2 November at St James' Park.

What do the goal numbers say about Newcastle and Everton?

Going by recent results, Newcastle have scored 6 and conceded 10 in their last 5 games. Meanwhile, Everton have scored 4 and conceded 6 in their last 5.

Will both teams score in Newcastle vs Everton?

The numbers give a clue: both teams scored in 3 of Newcastle's last 5 games. For Everton, the figure is 1 of 5.

18+ only. Above all, betting should stay fun. So set limits and keep control of your stakes. Free help is available at BeGambleAware.